Tuesday, September 4, 2012

Wonder Woman for President 2012: Gloria Steinem, Faith Ringgold, and Roger Ailes (by C. Smith)


“Peace and Justice '72” reads a cartoon sign, on the cover of Ms. Magazine, the issue that contained Steinem's essay “Women Voters Can't Be Trusted” appeared in the July 1972 Ms. magazine; the image of a concerned Wonder Woman rescuing a city block from the madness of war with her golden lasso appears on the magazine’s cover. Steinem’s enumeration of assumptions men make about trends in women as a voting bloc reflects the dramatic comic book image, published months before the Democratic National Convention would endorse both George McGovern as a candidate for President as well as an Equal Rights Amendment, as activists including Steinem, Germaine Greer, Shirley MacLaine and others supported Feminist candidate Shirley Chisholm. Tonight, forty years after the publication of Steinem’s essay, First Lade Michelle Obama will appear and speak onstage, in support of her husband; over the past year, Michelle Bachmann ran an unsuccessful campaign seeking the GOP nomination for President; four years ago, former Alaskan governor Sarah Palin was selected as John McCain's Vice President; last week, former Secretary of State Condoleeza Rice appeared before an invigorated crowd of Republicans, while this week’s Convention will be presided over by Debbie Wasserman-Shultz: during this year’s election, evidence of the increased political participation of women identifies some of the progress made since Ms. magazine’s publication of its ‘Wonder Woman for President’ cover, and Steinem’s description of assumptions.  

During this down-and-dirty election season: may a specific group of people still adhere to a candidate’s views because “[...] they fit our popular image as nonpolitical, limited people; an image we have internalized so well that we may accept it as true of women as a group, even though we have disproved it in our individual lives”(Steinem, 1972)? To what extent do we—across demographics of gender and age, income and race—consider ourselves a “nonpolitical, limited people,” willing to adopt one party’s set of political, social, economic, and ethical beliefs?

And how might we gather such critical information? If assumptions are to be made about any specific political demographic, evaluation of the mass media and news networks’ portrayal of that group may be useful. Do women vote differently than their husbands? I’d love to ask Roger Ailes, longtime political strategist and creator of the ‘fair and balanced’ news network: Ailes' ability to present political viewpoints as entertainment began during the Nixon administration; beyond helping devise a plan to televise the lighting of the White House Christmas tree, some allege the full conception of FoxNews as a machine of propaganda and media control took place in the Oval Office during the early 1970s. Ailes is important to a modern characterization of women’s role in politics, as his network consistently beats all competitors in monthly ratings. Ailes also claims Sarah Palin as his own creation: after the former Governor’s unsuccessful Presidential campaign alongside John McCain, Ailes’ network had a small studio installed in Palin's Wasilla, Alaska home. Her tenure with the network did not last as long as some had hoped; in a recent speech, Ailes admitted that he “hired Sarah Palin because she was hot and got ratings” (Ailes, as cited by Moore, 2011).

Steinem’s assessment of women as a voting bloc came at a time when chauvinism was probably more acceptable, but also when the mass media was in its infancy, and populations may have expected less interpretation of events from their newscasters. One quote from Steinem’s essay rings with the charged and staunch rhetoric of last week in Tampa: “Culturally, women tend to think like conservers of life. Sometimes that makes us conservative in the conventional sense, and sometimes it pushes us to the left, making us very radical indeed” (Steinem, 1972). What modern political party seeks to be “conservers of life,” and to what extent may this phrase be taken as an indentification of viewpoint on Roe V. Wade? Has our political language—the wearing out of terms and phrases, including conservative­—weakened our abilities of political representation?  

Actions may forever speak more loudly than words; according to a number of accounts, the Republican National Committee surprised those protesting their convention by providing boxed lunches to all those on the sidewalk.  Actions within realms of creativity appear mutually exclusive to those of media and politics; while Ailes’ criticism of his network news competition extends into aesthetic set design, the artistry involved in the cover of Ms. magazine may today be relegated to museums, over publications that reflect national concerns and culture (a recent comparison of Time magazine European and American editions reflects poorly on our national obsession with ourselves). But magazines, news networks, and political parties are inclusive organizations; the potential for individuals to express opinions and views, as artists, may still exist.

While Faith Ringgold’s 1988 story quilt “Tar Beach” extends an “angry, critical reappraisal” (Spector, 2012) of urban life and the possibility of experience through a vibrant, inviting and historic form, her 2000 project “Racial Questions and Answers” may be one of the Internet’s first examples of participatory asynchronous representation through art. While her history of political activism fed her experience in quilting (the most famous result of which hangs today in the Guggenheim), her website devoted to the collection of demographic data and speculation on racial identity reads like the registration page of an early social networking hub, as Ringgold’s collection of identifying data is followed by prompts of individual reflection, on an assumed racial identity: “Imagine Waking up One Morning Black in America!” reads part two, of her “Questionnaire A for White People.” A separate questionnaire, for “all people of color” proposes one wake up “One Morning White in America!” (Ringgold, 2000).  Ringgold’s latest creative efforts include a host of childrens’ books, for which she has received many accolades. How might Ringgold assess Steinem’s 1972 charge, that a specific population may not be trusted, relied upon, to support a politician’s set of values and social policies? Perhaps we may all strive to be like the child in her “Tar Beach” quilt, mid-flight and hovering above the stoic symbols of the most oppressive groups we know, together forging a voting bloc that is unfixed and critical, and cannot be trusted. Roger Ailes’ characterization, however, of the voting public’s likely behavior is probably honed in on populations within a few ‘swing states,’ while maintaining a widespread support for individuals’ participation as a “nonpolitical, limited people.”  

Hale, C. (2012). “Masterpiece Activity: Faith Ringgold’s Tar Beach.” Retrieved from http://www.scholastic.com/librarians/programs/tarbeach.htm

Gawker.com. (2012). “Roger Ailes' Secret Nixon-Era Blueprint for FoxNews.” Retrieved from http://gawker.com/5814150/roger-ailes-secret-nixon+era-blueprint-for-fox-news

Moore, R. (October 5 2011). “Roger Ailes: I Hired Sarah Palin Because She Was Hot and Got Ratings.”  Retrieved from http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/10/05/roger-ailes-sarah-palin-fox-news_n_995691.html


Steinem, G. (1972). “Women Voters Can’t Be Trusted.” Ms. [magazine]. Retrieved from http://www.msmagazine.com/spring2002/steinem.asp

(by Christopher Smith)

Saturday, August 25, 2012

The "other" - re: American Born Chinese

Jesse wrote a briliant take on "American Born Chinese" on the other forum. I think that as outsider we will always have only a limitted ability to see the "Other", therefore the only way that one can really make their voice heard is speaking up.
Edward Said (2005), Patricia Hills Collins (1986) and Carol Gilligan (1987) are three examples of scholars who protest the "incorrect" or mistaken way that the academia views their ethnic group or gender. I argue that there is no way to avoid a partial view of the other, even if we try to maintain the highest awareness possible and attempt to be fully attentive to the 'Other'. The only way to engage the other and to espier to more social justice is to be conscious and listen carefully to what the 'Other' is saying, and be open to the content and the format of what she sais, avoiding (as much as possible) preconceived conclusions. Eventually, it seems like the only way that someone who feels her is seen in a distorted way can change it, is to talk about her experience and bring it into the discourse, just as Said voiced his personal experience as an Arab, Gilligan interviewed women in addition to men and Collins brought her voice as a black woman into the scholarly discourse.
Hall (1997) states that Stereotyping is a common signifying practice. Stereotypes take simple memorable characteristics about a person, reduce everything about the person to those traits, exaggerate and simplify it and fix it without change or development to eternity. "Stereotyping reduces, essentialists, naturalizes and fixes 'difference' " (p. 258). Hall states that stereotyping is part of the maintenance of social and symbolic order, it is one of the mechanisms of boundary maintenance, a practice of 'closure' and exclusion. (p. 258) So that stereotyping is unavoidable. It is part of the way we naturally make sense of the world. However, it may lead to social in-justice and become a source of ethical problems. In the same time ignoring the fact the the "Other" is different may also cause social injustice.
This is clearly demonstrated in the case of Gilligan's research. Gilligan (1987), who taught and researched with Erikson and later with Kohlberg, found that the moral development standards that she was teaching did not feet her own thinking. She found that all the research was done exclusively with male subjects therefore the results did not take into account the different voice of women regarding this subject. As a result the evaluation scales developed based on this research advantaged men.
Gilligan's findings should alarm every one who is involved with research. Just like Erikson and Kohlberg, we all do our best to research issues with the most objective attitude possible. Yet, we can only perceive the issues we are studying using our pervious knowledge, thinking processes that we have learned and our system of values and beliefs. Just like Erikson and Kohlberg did not notice they are missing half of the population they are trying to study, we are bound to be blind to numerous aspects of our own research.
In this paper I will try to explore these issues using art work, with the intention of "trusting the process" and let it lead me to a smaller more focused point for discussion.



References:
1.     Alcoff, L, (1991). The problem of speaking for others. Cultural Critique.no.20 (pp. 5-32).
2.     Collins, P. H. (1986). Learning from the outsider within: The sociological significance of black feminist thought, Social Problems Vol 33, no 6 pp14-32
3.     Collins, P.H. (2000). Black feminist thought. London: Routledge.
4.     Foucault, M. (1984). The ethics of concern of the self as a practice of freedom Ethics subjectivity and truth. NY: The new press.
5.     Gilligan, C. (1982). In a different voice. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
6.     Gilligan, C. (1987). Moral orientation and moral development. Justice and care, ed. Held V. (1995). Colorado: West view.
7.     Hall, W.,ed. (1997). Representation. London: The open university.
8.     Said, E. (1978) Orientalism. (Hebrew Translation), Tel Aviv: Am Oved.   


Friday, August 24, 2012

Recycling of images in films - does it enhance memory or forgetfulness?

Recycling of images in films - does it enhance memory or forgetfulness?

I would like to offer an additional angle to "the truth about film" and the "rhetorical abilities of the camera". Most of our readings dealt with the ways film makers depict reality and create images of themselves and others. I would like to suggest, that an additional concern is how these images are than used, or recycled in other films and what is the impact of such use on the meaning of the original images. Does it reinforce the memory that these images carry to does it contribute to forgetting it?

Tobias Abrect (2012) states the use of iconic images of the holocaust in popular cinema is actually contributing to forgetting the original traumatic event. According to him, the holocaust became part of our universal collective memory. The images that became the symbol of a- historical total evil, are used not only for the memory of the holocaust but also for understanding other war horrors. "They became the visual foundation for our imaging of any horror that follows". This "migration" of images to other contexts, the use of the visual representation of the holocaust to cinematic and television images of other wars occurs internationally.
The films that were filmed by the allied forces while entering the concentration camps were recycled as iconic images for genocide. According to Abrect these images were used for films about the holocaust like Shindler's Lists (Spielberg, 1993), Memory of the camp (McAlister 1945) and more. However it was also used in films like Platoon (Stone 1986) about the Vietnam war. Abrect claims that Stone is using images from the holocaust (such as bulldozers shoving corpses to the graves). According to Abreact Stone creates a visual connection between the burial of the Vietnamese farmers and the Jewish victims of the holocaust to emphasize his notion that the Vietnam war was un justified. This "migration of images" stigmatizes historical events that are compared to the holocaust.
Furthermore, images from the holocaust appear in science fiction and fantasy movies as well: X- men (Singer, 2001). "V for Vendetta" (2006) and Shutter Island (Skorze 2010). Abrect states that the use of these images makes the narrative of the holocaust into a universal paradigm of moral.


References:
Abrecht, T. (2012). Iconic images of the holocaust in popular cinema. Yad Vashem (Heberw). Retrieved 15/8/2012 from http://www1.yadvashem.org/yv/he/education/newsletter/24/main_article.asp

Tuesday, August 21, 2012

The Truth about Film (Elizabeth Aiossa)



Valerie Smith's chapter, "The Documentary Impulse in Contemporary African-American Film," discusses the disparity in cultural and racial representations as seen in black fictional films and documentaries. Namely, Smith notes how the fictional films created by and depicting African-American community life rely on verisimilitude, the appearance of truth and factuality, when the documentaries, a nonfictional genre by convention, reveal instead the slipperiness of reality.  As hooks argues in her response to the absurd fears and institutional interventions surrounding the theatrical release of Boyz N the Hood, fictional films depicting urban black life, regardless of their attempted verisimilitude, potray sanitized and watered-down versions of our unjust and prejudicial world. It is for this fact, I suppose, that African-American documentarians were inspired to question and challenge rhetoric, generic conventions, and media representation. Independent filmmaking, for its lack of financial sponsorship strings, had the freedom to do so.  

 

While I agree with Chris that media and its markets have changed dramatically in the twenty years since Smith's chapter was published, I think Billips and Hatch's documentary style and design can still teach today's filmmakers how to construct and contribute alternative voices and depictions of themselves and their unique communities. As Smith details, Billips and Hatch et al. "trouble the boundary between fact and fiction" (60) when they "interweave dramatic re-enactments, pantomime, and fantasy sequences with archival footage and interviews o question ideologies […] and the adequacy of realist techniques of representation" (61). This lesson can return to inform fictional dramas as well, seeing that TV and film realties not bent solely on ratings and gross profit stand to learn from it, too.

 

I teach Introduction to Screenwriting at a community college in northern Illinois. Although our campus is only 40 minutes outside of Chicago, too many students assume that the news and TV and film representations of our local urban life adequately inform and represent this diverse and rich and too-segregated city and its citizens. I see how important it is to ask these emerging writers to challenge and change the media they script, whether for TV or film, fiction or documentary, in socially aware and conscientious ways. After all, a zombie film (as most of my students want to write, for some reason) is never just about zombies...

 

We, the creators of new media (art, essay, film, whathaveyou) need to stop replicating and perpetuating stereotypes and prejudice, censorship and the status quo. Now is the time, seeing as that the production and dissemination of our art is now democratized and in our hands.

 

I will share this chapter with my incoming class, and hope, at the very least, that each one of these writers contemplates the power they wield.     

Monday, August 20, 2012

Rhetorical Abilities of the Camera: Valerie Smith and James Allen

[by Christopher Smith]

The rhetorical capacity of the camera has changed both the way social protest is captured by onlookers, but has also helped to establish a means by which statements of political, social, or economic activism may help determine its efficacy—a new criteria was established during the twentieth century, of what "looks good" for the television and still cameras. From red carpet celebrity appearances to network television anchors to filmmakers and politicians, one's own appearance and voice transmitted across electronic means has become a new and fluid form of rhetoric. When Nixon sweated and stammered his way through televised, live, and unedited Presidential debates in 1960—and went on to lose the race to Kennedy—he hired a young and aspiring production assistant to help him "look good" on television, to present himself as newly calm and clear, stern and thoughtful. Within a decade, Nixon had an effective public image, the sum of the rhetoric crafted by a careful team (Joe McGinnis' The Selling of the President 1968 is a fantastic description of this transformative process)—and the young production assistant, Roger Ailes, would go on to create and head Fox News, on behalf of the Murdoch empire. How does the action of "looking good" take place today, in films, news, and on the wild and wicked web?

Context for Valerie Smith's work regarding films that appeal to specific racial groups is useful in understanding the lineage and evolution of our collective on-camera rhetoric. Since the time of her writing, some of her presumptions regarding the efficacy of documentary film may be challenged by the popularity of artists like Michael Moore, and the continued and heightened high regard for the works of Spike Lee. While "documentarians [still seem] unlikely to achieve the popularity of directors of fiction films" (p. 62), Smith's (1992) assumptions about the commercial viability of "nonfiction films" (p. 61) may have been unseated by a recent trend in nonfiction television, film and culture: reality television, now clearly established as a genre of popular entertainment, seeks the presentation—however awkwardly rendered—of individuals' narratives, without the façade sought by the rhetorical cameras of the twentieth century. Do reality television programs, from Hoarders to Hardcore Pawn, represent the "intimate, if not contiguous, relation to an externally verifiable reality" (p. 60) Smith identifies in the movies of the early 1990s? If Andy Warhol was correct, that we may all be delivered our requisite fifteen minutes of fame within the corporate portals of reality television, are producers interested in making individuals and their narratives 'look good?' What is the "intimate [and] externally verifiable reality" that can help define this emerging realm of nonfiction narrative?   
If Smith's characterization of the import and reception of black feature films in 1992 was critical to the development of rhetoric and representation in film, James Allen's website Without Sanctuary serves as contrast: without the expectations of a manufactured plot, a rising action, and a benevolent resolution sandwiched between segments of corporate commercials, Allen's work in compiling images, and their presentation on a web page, helps establish a genre technologically unavailable at the time of Smith's writing. Self-described 'picker' James Allen, narrating the short film declared that, "in America, everything is for sale, even a national shame" (2005). He describes how his collecting and presenting photographic postcards of lynchings across the United States during the early 1900s has "engendered" in him a fear of "the majority," and how a specific "image layered a pall of grief over my fears." Those who peruse his site are witness to scenes of horrific and public death; the viewer endures "the endless replay of anguish," as Allen ruminates and speculates about the motivations of those depicted as watching the hangings and swaying bodies. Is such a website—a work of visual rhetoric, devised specifically to represent moments when citizens have looked far from 'good' but perhaps at their most reprehensible and repugnant—effective, as an act of protest, of representation long after the grave facts? Does the visual representation of individuals or groups looking 'less-than-good' at moments in history constitute an act of protest?
Websites may have helped reinforce Allen's notion that "in America, everything is for sale"; a published collection of his images remains available, though their representation online may have undermined his profits. Allen's website includes an active and public forum, in which comments on the lynching photographs from educators, students, and web users at large have sought to make meaning of and increase understanding of what Allen described in his short film as "the cold steel trigger in the human heart"—what drove these crowds to these terrible moments. Discussions found on the forum provided unique and fluid contextualization for the collection. One participant, username ansar1013, posted on August 11, 2011, under the "Where Was God?" thread on the Without Sanctuary website: "I am here to establish a system of justice in this world and replace this current system of injustice. These lynchings that were done can only be blamed on the cowards and punks in the crowd that lacked the testicular fortitude to fight for right. People know what is right from wrong. We just lack the balls to do something about it. So instead of getting bogged down into some GOD talk we should discuss strategies and tactics to completely destroy this current system of injustice" (ansar1013, 2011). Theological arguments, pedagogical applications, and individuals' constructive criticism all aid in making sense of Allen's photographic documentary; perhaps the site remains proof that we, as a culture and population, are still seeking full context for the rhetorical abilities of the camera. The creative genre that accommodates the compilation and distribution of images (of others, taken by others) may still be evolving. Perhaps we are still trying to understand what it means to 'look good' on film, and in the digital age. The choices in 'looking good' that are ours and in the present-tense are not the same as the choices made by those in the past: be them crowds gathered around trees for nefarious and horrific reasons during the first decade of the last century, or the populations represented by filmmakers twenty years ago.
Allen, J. (2005). Without Sanctuary [film]. Retrieved from http://withoutsanctuary.org
Ansar1013. (11 Aug. 2011). "Where Was God?" [forum post]. Retrieved from http://withoutsanctuary.org/main.html
Smith, V. "The Documentary Impulse in Contemporary African American Film." In Black Popular Culture: A Project by Michele Wallace, ed. Gina Dent. Seattle: Bay Press, 1992.

Sunday, August 19, 2012

Thunderheart - We Women Warriors

Thunderheart - We Women Warriors by Raul Manzano
 
"Old Cowboys New Indians," an article by T.V. Reed is based on three films of the American Indian Movement as depicted by American's film authority, Hollywood. For this assignment, I will focus on the film Thunderheart which I viewed. I will also address the film We Women Warriors which was recently shown in New York City. A documentary based on Indigenous people in Colombia, S.A.
The plot of the film "Thunderheart" is the investigation of a murder case where an Indian has been accused of the crime. The FBI is in charge of the case for which agent Val Kilmer, whose background is half Indian, is sent to work along guru investigator Sam Shepard. Kilmer finds himself in a cross-road between the White world and Indian culture as he is confronted by members of the Indian community; his facial features revealed his Indian ethnicity he could not hide behind his RayBan shades. As he tries to stay firm to his White upbringing and conduct a professional investigation, he begins to realize there is more to the crime. Along the way, he meets spiritual leader or grandfather, as he is called, who instill in him the power of self reflection, sharing traditional values, customs, and beliefs in the laws of nature. He also tells him there is a reason why he has been called to this investigation. Soon Kilmer begins to put clues together to find out that the investigation is a set-up to accuse an Indian of a crime he did not do. The land the tribe inhabits is uranium rich which is being exploited by a mining company, in the process the river waters have been contaminated by the mineral extraction process. The Indian who was killed discovered why his people have been dying but he is silenced by a sniper. The plot thickens as Kilmer finds out that his boss is involved in the cover-up with direct ties to the government, which makes Kilmer a disposable person. As he uncovered more information, he is pursued by hunters and the police in a car chase coming to a dead-end in a deserted mountain area but he is saved by the force of the Indian tribe that has come together to his aid. At that point, Kilmer realized his own identity and the power of the spiritual world.  While the film focused on a crime solving investigation, the true story is about the treatment and displacement of the Indians that for over five hundred years have been driven to no-man's-land and when they finally settled, they are poisoned by American capitalism.
 
On the other hand, the film We Women Warriors is an important documentary on the lives of indigenous women that stood up against violence and the lack of government protection. Caught up in the cross-fired between guerrillas and military forces (and paramilitares), they struggle to survive in a war that is not theirs. Using non-violent protest, they achieved milestone recognition but the fight is not over as long as the drug trafficking trade and guerrilla-government conflicts continues. Their lives are at risk. It is interesting to know how technology has aided them in their cause by using laptops and cell phones. Those women, with their limited education, showed the power of determination to change and build a constructive environment, more importantly, to preserve their indigenous population and culture. Their protest became a national debate thereby obtaining political rights to govern themselves. After all these years, finally the Indigenous population of Colombia have their voices heard. A statement on the producers website about Indigenous human rights reads: "When the UN Declaration on Rights of Indigenous Peoples was passed in 2007, the United States, Canada and Colombia were the only countries that abstained from endorsing it. Two years later, Colombia's Constitutional Court ruled that the Colombian government must do more to protect the country's 102 aboriginal nations, 32 of which are in danger of extinction because of the armed conflict. These events contributed to Colombian government's endorsement of the U.N. Declaration Rights of Indigenous Peoples in May 2009. Canada and the U.S. just recently endorsed this critical human rights charter in 2010."
 
Both films show the treatment and discrimination Indigenous people have suffered since the White man landed in the Américas. Thunderheart portraits Native American Indians living in deplorable conditions and their struggles to survive under White man laws, while We Women Warriors depicts harsh living conditions caused by another White man's exploitation: drug trade.
 
Works Cited:
Thunderheart. Dir. Michael Apted. Perf. by Val Kilmer, Sam Shepard, Graham Greene. 1992.
 
Todos los Pueblos Productions. We Women Warriors. Web. 18 Aug. 2012. <http://wewomenwarriors.com/directors-statement.html>.
 
We Women Warriors. Dir. Nicole Karsin. Perf. by Doris, Ludis and Flor Ilva Trochez. (2002-2009) 2011.

Wednesday, August 8, 2012



Tolken, in "The anguish of snails: Native American Folklore in the West offers an interesting account of the development of Native American dance as a reflection of the changes in the Native American Society.
The part of her analysis that caught my attention even more was when she suggests a new kind of inquiry. She suggest: "—for our inquiry and insight—let’s ask not, “Why are they dancing?” or “What are they dancing about?” but rather, “What are they dancing?” That is to say, what is embodied in a particular dance while people are performing it? What do the accumulated patterns “say” to us?"

" Just as visual art allows us to create concrete objects to articulate complex cultural values, just as stories and songs allow the expression of cultural ideas in the patterns of oral performance, so dance allows us to dramatize, to act out, to embody a set of
ideas or values which otherwise would remain unarticulated" (80).

As an illustration for this idea (with some refrence to last week's discussion)
 I would like to share with you this image:

Moriya, 120/90 cm